Not just "which costs less a month" — buying builds home equity that renting doesn't, but renting frees up your deposit (and any month it's cheaper than buying) to be invested instead. This compares what you'd actually be left with: home equity plus any side investments vs a pure investment portfolio.
Adjust your numbers
Covers Stamp Duty / Land Transaction Tax / Land and Buildings Transaction Tax plus legal fees and survey — a flat percentage here rather than the exact bands, which differ by nation and buyer type (first-time buyer, additional property, etc).
The assumed growth rate for whichever side is investing a monthly surplus — and, for the renter, their un-spent deposit from day one.
Ongoing costs & horizon
How long until you'd sell (buying) or stop renting to compare (renting) — not necessarily the same as the mortgage term.
Buying / month (mortgage + maintenance)£1,751
Renting / month (today)£1,200
Over 10 years, buying leaves you £74,557 wealthier than renting and investing the difference. Buying overtakes renting around year 3.
Net wealth after 10 years
Buying£200,949
Renting£126,392
Home equity (after selling costs & mortgage) Investment portfolio
What this doesn't cover: exact Stamp Duty/LTT/LBTT bands (a flat percentage is used instead), remortgaging or rate changes over time, moving costs if you'd rent multiple different places, void periods or landlord costs the rent doesn't reflect, tax on investment gains outside a tax-free wrapper (assumes the side portfolio is roughly ISA-like), and market volatility — house prices, rents, and investment returns are all assumed to grow smoothly at a constant rate, which real markets never do.
Frequently asked questions
Is it cheaper to rent or buy a house in the UK?
It depends on far more than the monthly payment. Buying builds equity but comes with one-off costs (stamp duty, legal fees, moving), maintenance and selling costs, while renting frees up your deposit to invest. This calculator compares your overall wealth under both after a set number of years, which is a fairer test than comparing rent with a mortgage payment.
How long do I need to stay in a home for buying to be worth it?
Buying usually needs several years to win, because the upfront buying costs and eventual selling costs have to be outweighed by equity built up and house price growth. The shorter your time horizon, the more likely renting and investing the difference comes out ahead — try changing the horizon in the calculator to see the break-even point for your numbers.
What costs of buying a home do people often forget?
Beyond the deposit and mortgage payments: stamp duty (for anything above the first-time buyer or standard threshold), solicitor and survey fees, mortgage arrangement fees, moving costs, buildings insurance, ongoing maintenance and repairs — often estimated at around 1% of the property's value a year — and estate agent fees when you eventually sell.
Does renting mean throwing money away?
Not necessarily. Mortgage interest, maintenance and buying and selling costs are also money you don't get back. Renting can leave you better off if you invest the deposit and any monthly savings consistently, and if your investments grow faster than house prices — buying tends to win when house prices grow strongly or rents rise quickly.