Spare cash each month — pay it onto the mortgage, or invest it instead? Overpaying gives you a guaranteed return equal to your mortgage rate (every pound off the balance is a pound of interest you'll never pay). Investing isn't guaranteed, but has more room to grow. This compares net wealth — investment portfolio minus what you still owe — under both.
Adjust your numbers
Most fixed-rate deals only allow penalty-free overpayments up to around 10% of the balance per year — check yours before overpaying beyond that, or you may trigger an early repayment charge.
Assumes the invested side sits in a tax-free wrapper like a Stocks & Shares ISA — no dividend tax or Capital Gains Tax modelled, the same simplification the rent-vs-buy and buy-to-let tools make for their side portfolios.
Normal monthly payment£1,112
Interest saved by overpaying£42,365
Paid off7 yr 2 mo early
Over 25 years, overpaying the mortgage leaves you £277 wealthier than investing the spare cash.
Net wealth after 25 years
Overpay mortgage£137,672
Invest instead£137,395
Guaranteed vs uncertain: overpaying's return is locked in — it's exactly your mortgage rate, every time. The investment return here is just an assumption; a real portfolio could do better or worse than 5.0%/yr, especially over shorter horizons. The lower the gap between your mortgage rate and expected investment return, the more that uncertainty matters relative to the reward.
What this doesn't cover: early repayment charges beyond your lender's penalty-free overpayment allowance, remortgaging or rate changes over the term (assumes today's rate stays fixed for the whole period), and tax on investment gains outside an ISA-like wrapper.
Frequently asked questions
Is it better to overpay my mortgage or invest?
Overpaying gives a guaranteed, tax-free 'return' equal to your mortgage interest rate. Investing can earn more over the long term, but returns aren't guaranteed. As a rule of thumb, the higher your mortgage rate compared to the returns you expect after fees, the stronger the case for overpaying — and many people split the difference by doing some of each.
How much can I overpay my mortgage without a penalty?
Many UK lenders let you overpay up to 10% of the outstanding balance each year during a fixed or discounted deal without an early repayment charge, but the limit varies, so check your mortgage terms. Once you're on the lender's standard variable rate, there's usually no limit.
Should I pay into my pension instead of overpaying the mortgage?
Pension contributions get tax relief at your marginal rate (and National Insurance savings too if made through salary sacrifice), which is a large head start that neither overpaying nor ISA investing has. The trade-off is access: pension money is locked away until at least age 57 from 2028, whereas an overpaid mortgage reduces your debt straight away.
Does overpaying reduce my monthly payment or my mortgage term?
It depends on your lender — some automatically reduce your monthly payment, others shorten the term, and many let you choose. Shortening the term saves more interest overall, while reducing the payment gives you more flexibility each month.