Pension vs ISA vs DIY investing

The same amount of take-home pay, invested at the same assumed growth rate, in three different UK tax wrappers. Figures use 2026/27 rates for pension tax relief, the £500 Dividend Allowance, and the £3,000 Capital Gains Tax allowance.

Adjust your numbers

The amount you're giving up from your take-home pay — the fair, common basis to compare all three on, since the pension gets a bigger gross contribution for the same net cost.

The portion of the DIY account's return paid out as taxable dividends each year, rather than untaxed-until-sold capital growth. Doesn't apply inside the pension or ISA — both are tax-free wrappers regardless of dividend yield.

Fees & assumptions

Platform + fund charges, deducted from growth every year. This is usually where DIY's edge comes from — a cheap index tracker can undercut a default workplace pension fund or a platform-bundled ISA by 0.5%+ a year, which compounds a lot over decades.

Applied to the taxable 75% of the pension when it's drawn — often lower than your working-age rate, which is a big part of a pension's advantage.

At £40,000, you're a basic rate taxpayer for dividends and Capital Gains Tax — this uses the UK-wide thresholds, which apply the same way whether you're in England & Wales. Pension contributions get relief at 28.0% (Income Tax + National Insurance), so £3,000/year of take-home pay becomes £4,167/year in the pension.

What you'd actually walk away with, after 20 years

Pension£112,842
ISA£98,913
DIY (general account)£96,592
WrapperContributedPot before exit taxTax paidNet
Pension£83,333£132,756£19,913£112,842
ISA£60,000£98,913£0£98,913
DIY£60,000£101,204£5,583£96,592

DIY's "Tax paid" includes dividend tax paid each year along the way, plus Capital Gains Tax on the total gain when the account is sold at the end.

What this doesn't cover: the £20,000 annual ISA allowance, the pension annual allowance (£60,000) or the £268,275 cap on tax-free pension lump sums — unlikely to bind at typical contribution levels, but worth knowing about if you're investing close to those limits. It also assumes a constant salary, tax band, and growth rate for the whole period, and that the DIY account is sold in one go at the end rather than drawn down gradually (drawing it down slowly, using the CGT allowance fresh each year, would usually owe less CGT overall than this shows).

Frequently asked questions

Is a pension or an ISA better?

A pension gets tax relief on the way in at your marginal Income Tax rate, and 25% can usually be taken tax-free, but the rest is taxed as income when you withdraw it, and you can't access it until at least 55 (57 from 2028). An ISA has no tax relief on the way in, but everything comes out tax-free and you can access it at any time. For most higher-rate taxpayers, the pension usually wins on numbers alone.

How much can I put into an ISA and a pension each year?

The ISA allowance is £20,000 a year across all your ISAs. For pensions, the annual allowance is £60,000 (or 100% of your earnings, if lower), including employer contributions — lower for very high earners and for anyone who has already started flexibly drawing their pension.

How are investments outside an ISA or pension taxed?

In a general investment account, dividends above the £500 Dividend Allowance are taxed (at 10.75%, 35.75% or 39.35% for 2026/27, depending on your band), and gains above the £3,000 Capital Gains Tax allowance are taxed at 18% or 24% when you sell. Low fees can partly offset this, which is what the 'DIY' column in this calculator shows.

How much tax-free cash can I take from my pension?

Usually 25% of your pension, up to a lifetime limit of £268,275 (the lump sum allowance) for most people. The rest is taxed as income when you withdraw it, at whatever rate applies to your total income that year.