A PCP's optional final payment is structurally the same thing as an interest-only mortgage's capital due at term end: lower monthly payments because you're only paying down to a residual value, not to zero. HP fully repays like a normal repayment loan — you own the car outright at the end, no balloon. This compares the total cost of all three, and whether investing PCP's lower monthly payment beats just doing HP.
Adjust your numbers
Only affects PCP — the lump sum you'd pay at the end to own the car, instead of handing it back. HP doesn't have one (it's fully repaid by the end).
For the "invest PCP's saving" comparison below — assumes a tax-free wrapper like a Stocks & Shares ISA, the same simplification the mortgage-overpay-invest tool makes.
HP monthly payment£689
PCP monthly payment£467
PCP saves you / month£222
Total cost to own the car by the end of the term
Cash£25,000
HP£27,818
PCP (incl. paying the balloon)£28,825
PCP costs £1,007 more than HP to actually own the car, for the same price/APR/term — deferring more of the principal to the end means a higher average balance (and so more interest) throughout.
The balloon is a real payment due: to own the car at the end of a PCP deal you need £9,000 in one go — pay it, part-exchange the car against it, or refinance it. If you can't, and haven't invested the monthly saving to cover it, your only option is to hand the car back and own nothing.
Does investing PCP's saving beat just doing HP?
Both start from the same deposit and owe the same amount at first. HP pays it off in full every month. PCP pays less each month — this invests that £222 difference, and compares the growing pot (minus what's still owed on each) to see which actually leaves you wealthier.
Over the 3 yr term, the invested pot (£8,535) doesn't cover the £9,000 balloon — you'd be £465 short of owning the car outright, worse off than just doing HP.
What this doesn't cover: the balloon here is whatever you set it to — a real PCP deal's optional final payment is set by the lender based on predicted depreciation, mileage allowance, and condition, and you're charged for exceeding the agreed mileage. Doesn't model insurance, servicing, or maintenance cost differences between finance types (some PCP/HP deals bundle these), part-exchange scenarios, or early settlement costs. Cash isn't included in the wealth comparison above — "spend the whole price now, invest nothing" is a different question from "which finance product leaves you wealthier."
Frequently asked questions
Is PCP or HP cheaper?
For the same price, APR and term, HP almost always costs less in total interest than PCP if your goal is to actually own the car — PCP's lower monthly payments come from paying down to a residual "balloon" value instead of £0, which means a higher average balance, and more interest, over the term.
What happens if I don't pay the PCP balloon payment?
You simply hand the car back at the end of the agreement and owe nothing further, assuming you've stayed within the agreed mileage and condition terms — that's the "optional" in optional final payment. You just don't end up owning the car, unlike with HP or paying cash.
Is it better to buy a car with cash or finance it?
Paying cash avoids interest entirely, so it's the cheapest option in pure cost terms. Financing instead can make sense if the money you'd have spent on the car would otherwise earn more invested than the finance APR costs you — though that's not guaranteed the way avoiding interest is.